Friday, April 29, 2016

Constituency Relations in Campaign Implementation

It can be extremely helpful to to establish constituency relations in program (or campaign) implementation.  Constituency relations in health promotion refers to, "the process of convening, exchanging information and establishing and maintaining strategic relationships with key stakeholders and organizations with the intent of identifying common goals that can contribute to the outcomes of specific communication program or health-related mission" (Shiavo, n.d).

Just from the definition can you identify reasons why this type of relationship would be beneficial!? These relationships can help pool resources and advance health and social goals by strengthening the credibility and relevance of a social issue.  While there are several benefits in these types of relationships, establishing a working partnership may be more challenging than you or your organization originally intended. According to Shiavo, the following three components can assist in a successful partnership:

  • Identify someone within your organization to be a champion in outreach and relations
  • Emphasize teamwork, listening, and negation, as well as balancing needs and sharing credit with success with other organizations
  • Train staff members
  • Share results with other departments or organizations
Additionally, to ensure a successful partnership, it is imperative to ensure proper communication in order to establish organizational goals and objectives as well as who is responsible for what task with in each organization.  This will make sure everyone is on the same side of the cliff... 



Schiavo, R. Health communication.
http://www.teamworkandleadership.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/effective-communication-at-work.jpg 

Friday, April 15, 2016

The Digital Age

Health care and public health social marketing isn't quite as simple as it once was.  While this era presents more complexity, it also presents SO many more options to reach the target audience!

Hang on... before you read any further, I want you to count how many digital means you can think of to spread health messages... How many did you come up with? 5? 10? 15? 20!?

Yea, there's are a lot!  Because of this, I'm not going to go into detail about all of them or even list them all.  That being said, I listed a few areas I find particularly interesting or important.

Social media as a tool for health communications:
  • Youtube: This health advertisement links directly to youtube!  You can also use Youtube to share longer videos that go in-depth about a health topic.


  • Blog (like this one!)
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • eCards (do people still use these?)
  • Flickr
  • Buttons and Badges
  • Podcasts 
  • Widgets 
Those are only a few out of the great many social media options. If you're interested in social media as a means of health communication I would highly recommend checking out the CDC's Health Communicator's Social Media Toolkit!

mHealth
mHealth= mobile health.  This type of service is also becoming increasingly popular and can be particularly advantageous to rural populations or low-income countries who would normally have limited access to a physicians or health messaging.  mHealth can be used for health education and awareness, disease surveillance, helplines, diagnostic and treatment support (including telemedicine, where a patient never has to be seen in person by a real doctor).  Of course, ethically, this type of medicine can present many challenges, most notably, patient confidentiality.

Serious Gaming
Serious gaming is the use of games to deliver a serious message (as the name suggests).  Pretty cool stuff, although not simple or cheap to design and implement. Here's a link with several examples: https://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/games.html.  In addition to these games that teach you about a certain topic, there are other computerized games that use 3D body images as an interactive tool to explain how lifestyle behaviors can affect overall health.  Lastly, some digitalized serious games get the participant out and about by using an application on your mobile device, this promotes physical activity and community engagement. 

Ethical Concerns:  
Confidentiality and ensuring identity is a concern with many areas of digital medicine or heath communications.  For example, if one wants to use mobil devices as an option for medical diagnostic and/or treatment there has to be a mechanism in place to confirm both the provider and patients' identity.  This is partly just to make sure these individuals are who they say they are, however, it is also important in ensuring confidentiality.  If a patient is in care for HIV, the provider must insure their diagnosis does not become known to family members who also have access to the mobil device. 

Sunday, April 10, 2016

Cultural Relevancy in Health Promotion

Cultural relevancy is a big issue in health promotion!  Since this class started in January, we have read several pieces on cultural relevancy.  Ultimately, this topic incorporates both considerations about the target audience as well as framing the message in a way that is culturally acceptable.

Some concepts to keep in mind when developing a culturally relevant campaign are:

  • The knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, values, norms, customs, traditions, artifacts mores, folkways of the campaign's target audiences
  • Subcultures
  • Language
  • Cultural sensitivity 
  • Cultural identity
  • Lifestyle
  • Community
  • Identity affiliation
  • Cultural segmentation
  • Cross-Cultural Communication
  • Cultural differences in interpersonal communication
  • Acculturation 
As you can see in this health promotion campaign, several of the afore mentioned concepts were addressed.  The campaign is in the local language, featuring culturally appropriate clothing and housing structure.  Additionally, it is addressing knowledge, attitudes, believes, and norms by encouraging women to take vitamins even after the baby has been born. 

Another way several countries have utilized health education and promotion is through entertainment.  This is called Educational Entertainment or EE.  Two prime examples of EE are Soul Buddyz and Soul City in South Africa and The Archers in the UK.  


The archers was the first ever and longest running EE, originating in 1951 on the radio through BBC.  This program began as a soap opera that delivered educational message for agriculture.  Over the years, several issues have been covered and the current action line is on stopping domestic violence. 


Soul Buddyz and Soul City is a multi-media campaign utilizing radio, TV, comic books, workbooks, etc. and is broad cast in 9 languages.  This EE has also tackled a variety of health and social issues over the years with the highest ranking episode on domestic violence.  In this episode, community members banged pots and pans together when they knew domestic violence had occurred in a fellow community members home.  Not only was this the highest ranking episode, the technique of banging pots and pans together to stop domestic violence was later used in a real community!  Talk about impact! 

The Archers - BBC Radio 4. (2016). BBC. Retrieved 10 April 2016, from http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b006qpgr

Soul Buddyz Television Series - Tomorrow is ours — The Soul City Institute for Health & Development Communication. (2016). Soulcity.org.za. Retrieved 10 April 2016, from http://www.soulcity.org.za/projects/soul-buddyz

Fear Tactics in Health Promotion

While fear appeal in health promotion tends to be a widely debated concept... Does it work?  Does it not work?...  There are a few guiding principles that should be used along with this tactic. The following video sums this research and related guidelines up pretty well. 



And here are two examples where health promotion campaigns use fear as a prevention technique.  What do you think?





(2016). 2.bp.blogspot.com. Retrieved 10 April 2016, from https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiMJAfqhDXh6MGAsHKu0sSB7nqe5B9unHY62K6IS_w1o9Qf-CbTzSCjJvcy3Xmg44sZ1WP5NHNdQnY9sFpYAku7GAX_Rqd-vcOIZCR_h0DNZmkj2BSBNHJK2FjKK16Csh8Mbeike_Zq_rU/s640/meth_lipstick.jpg

Birkett, A. (2016). Fear and Greed: What Drives Human Behavior?ConversionXL. Retrieved 10 April 2016, from http://conversionxl.com/fear-and-greed/

Do Scare Tactics Work? A Meta-Analytic Test of Fear Appeal Theories - Association for Psychological Science. (2013). Psychologicalscience.org. Retrieved 10 April 2016, from http://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/video/do-scare-tactics-work-a-meta-analytic-test-of-fear-appeal-theories.html 



Thursday, March 31, 2016

The 4 P's!

It’s time to develop the marketing strategy!  The 4 P’s (product, price, place and promotion) will now be described to assist in this process.

Product Platform:

First, product strategy!
A product is anything that can be offered to a market to satisfy a want or need, it can be: physical goods, a service, an experience, an event, a person, a place, a property, an organization, information, or an idea. In social marketing, many campaigns include:
  • Benefit the target audience wants in exchange for performing the behavior
  • Any goods and services you will be promoting to your target audience
  • Any additional product elements you will include to assist your target audience in performing the behavior
When developing the product it is important to keep in mind the following three levels:
  • Core Product- the benefit the audience wants in exchange for performing the behavior
    • What’s in it for the customer to adopt the behavior?
    • What problem(s) will it solve?
    • What needs will the desired behavior satisfy?
    •  Ethical considerations: the core product suggest the benefit an individual will receive if they perform a behavior, however, how can you really ensure this is true. Also, how much should you disclose about the probability of success if you cannot ensure this level of success will be attained?
  • Actual product- any tangible goods and services you will promote
    • Could be existing goods or services or new goods or services
    • Ethical considerations: decisions have to be made relative to the specific behavior being promoted. For example, providing discounted, at home drug and alcohol tests for parents to use with their teens.  Could this create worse consequences for the family structure than the positive effects of keeping teens safe?  Another ethical consideration for the product is to examine how visible a funder’s name is in the campaign.
  • Augmented product- additional product elements to support behavior change
    • These are sometimes considered optional but may be what the individual needs for encouragement, removing barriers, or sustaining the behavior
    •  These could also present an opportunity to brand the campaign to create more attention, appeal and memorability
    •  Ethical Considerations: ethical considerations in this case could be more relevant if campaigns are tax funded, aka, did this program “performed as promised”. 
Additional information about the product:
Thinking forward to product design, it may be more beneficial to use design thinking.  This means focusing less on the object and more on an approach to designing products that fulfill human desires, solve problems, and create world-changing innovations, which were brought up in the core product.


Should your product have a brand?  While brands in social marketing are not as common as in the commercial sector the use of a brand (any name, term, sign, symbol or design) that identifies the product as being unique could be beneficial in the marketing campaign.

Price:

Price is the cost the target audience associates with adopting the desired behavior and includes four dimensions including: monetary incentives and disincentives & nonmonetary incentives and disincentives.  Monetary items are usually associated with any good or service that is needed to adopt a behavior.  Nonmonetary items are intangible and include costs such as time, effort, energy, psychological risk and physical discomforts.  when developing the price, it is important to increase the benefits or decrease the costs, this can be done through:
  •  Increasing monetary benefits for the desired behavior
    • Example: providing a 3.5 cent credit for using your own grocery bag or giving a $5 gift card for blood donations
  •  Increasing nonmonetary benefits for the desired behavior
    • Example: offering an extra point for hocky teams who do not receive any penalties
  • Decreasing monetary costs for desired behavior
    • Example: offering coupons for bike helmets
  • Decrease nonmonetary costs for the desired behavior
    •  Example: offering detailed maps and signs where produce can be purchased by WIC customers at farmers markets
  • Increase monetary costs for the competing behavior
    • Example: impose fines for those who text and drive
  • Increase nonmonetary costs for the competing behavior
    • Example: encouraging teens to develop their own messages and provide personal reasons for delaying sex in a teen abstinence campaign
While prices for tangible goods and services are normally set by retailers and producers, social marketers can decide what good and services would be beneficial in facilitating a behavior change, suggest discounts and incentives, and promote their use.

Ethical Considerations:  Social equity, potential exploitation, public shame, and full disclosure of costs all come into question when discussing pricing.  These are all fantastic ethical considerations and one must ensure to address them when determining the price for the product.

Place:

Location, Location, Location!  “Place in social marketing is where and when the target audience will perform the desired behavior, acquire goods, and receive associated services.”

Develop a place strategy:
  • Make the location close to the target audience
  • Make the location appealing
  • Be where your target audience shops
  • Be where your target audience hangs out
  • Extend hours
  • Be present at the time when the target audience will make a decision
  • Overcome psychological barriers associated with place
  • Be more accessible than the competition 
  • Make access to competition more difficult or unpleasant
  • Work with existing distribution channels
Ethical Issues:  The ethical issues surrounding place often arise when considering distribution channels and their equity and/or unintended consequences.  One way to tackle the issue of equity is to add more places at more times.  Overcoming unintended consequences may be slightly more difficult, however, social marketers can implement pilot programs with the intention of measuring behavior change and thus use these data for future campaign implementation.

The Last P- Promotion:

Promotion is, “Giving your brand a voice and establishing a dialog with your consumers.”

A 1-2 page creative brief can be an effective way to establish clear, meaningful, believable and distinctive messages while ensuring all team members are on board.  Typical elements in the creative brief are:
  • Purpose of communications
  • Target audience
  • Communication objectives
  •  Positioning statement
  •  Benefits to promise
  • Support for the promise
  • Style and tone
  • Openings
Moving forward to developing the message strategy, it's important to keep in mind that this is focused on what the actual content of your message will be and will answer the questions:  What do you want your target audience to do? What do you want them to know? What do you want them to believe?  The messages can be one sided (telling all the good) or two sided (mentioning product shortcomings).  When picking how many sides you want your message to have, research suggests that one-sided messages are generally more accepted by those who already favor your product, while two-sided messages may be more accepted by those who oppose your product.  It’s also important to consider what stage of change your target audience is currently in while developing the message.

Creative strategy (how do get from the content to the specific communications):
  • Keep it simple and clear
  • Focus on audience benefits
  • When using fear, follow up with solutions and use credible sources
  • Try for messages that are vivid, concrete, and personal
  • Make messages easy to remember
  • Have a little fun sometimes  (the opposite of fear based messages)
  • Try for a BIG IDEA
  • Consider a question instead of a nag
  • Make norms more visible
  • Tell real stories about real people
  • Try crowdsourcing
  • Appeal to psychographic characterizes and desires of the target audience
When you’ve gotten all this done… Don’t forget to PRETEST your overall message before moving forward in the process!

Ethical Considerations: Please try your best to make sure your messages are accurate and not misleading and that the language and graphics are clear and appropriate for exposed audiences.  The question is; whose criteria should you use?  (most of the time it will be the funders criteria).


Kotler, P. & Lee, N. (2016). Social Marketing: Changing behaviors for good.  Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.